Original Italian Pizza Stewartstown

4.0 ( 184 reviews )
$10–20
5 W Pennsylvania Ave, Stewartstown, PA 17363, United States
+1 717-993-5555

Original Italian Pizza Stewartstown, located at 5 W Pennsylvania Ave, offers a delightful experience that merges quality food with exceptional service. Customers like Patrick Quesenberry rave about the amazing pizza and stellar staff, highlighting that it’s simply one of the best places to enjoy a slice. The Chicago stuffed pizza, recommended by Ashley Rohleder, has become a standout dish, praised for its rich flavors and satisfying depth — truly a “chef’s kiss” moment!

Oscar Perez’s enthusiasm for the salads, particularly the fajita style salad, showcases the restaurant's versatility beyond pizza. It’s not just about dough and cheese; the chicken is tender and perfectly seasoned, making it an excellent choice for those seeking something lighter.

The atmosphere is inviting, and the commitment of the new owners to customer satisfaction shines through every interaction. As Itz Nadi experienced, beyond just pizza, the steak burger and complimentary pizza portions came as a delightful surprise, underscoring their dedication to excellent service and culinary delight.

With a menu that celebrates Italian flavors and a team that prioritizes customer care, Original Italian Pizza Stewartstown is a must-visit for food lovers in the area. Whether you indulge in a classic pizza or try something unique, it's a culinary adventure you won’t want to miss.

Amenities and More

  • Service options
    • Kerbside pickup
    • No-contact delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
    • Delivery
  • Popular for
    • Lunch
    • Dinner
    • Solo dining
  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Offerings
    • Comfort food
    • Quick bite
    • Small plates
  • Dining options
    • Lunch
    • Dinner
    • Catering
    • Dessert
    • Seating
    • Table service
  • Amenities
    • Toilet
  • Atmosphere
    • Casual
    • Cosy
  • Crowd
    • Family friendly
    • Groups
    • LGBTQ+ friendly
    • Transgender safe space
  • Planning
    • Accepts reservations
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards
  • Children
    • Good for kids
    • High chairs
    • Kids' menu
  • Parking
    • Free of charge street parking
    • Free parking lot
    • Parking

Reviews For Original Italian Pizza Stewartstown

Patrick Quesenberry
Jun 25,2025
One of the BEST pizzas ever the staff is amazing and food is great. What more could you ask for in a pizza shop!
Oscar Perez
Jun 10,2025
I will highly recommend having the salads. We had the fajita style salad and the chicken was tasty and not over spiced. Loved it’s.
Ashley Rohleder
May 26,2025
We got the Chicago stuffed pizza with tomato as the topping. Literal chef kiss! So happy to see this place under new ownership. The new owners have a lot of pride in what they provide! They were very customer service oriented. Honestly best pizza out of here since we moved here 5 years ago. Give them some grace as they settle in! They provide a super quality pizza. Don't sleep on the Chicago stuffed pizza.
Itz Nadi
Apr 30,2025
I had an amazing experience at the best Italian pizza place in town! I went there to try something different and ordered their steak burger with fries and a drink can you believe it only cost me 8? The food was incredible. The fries and burger were so flavorful it felt like a party in my mouth. And as if that wasn’t enough, they surprised me with two small portions of pizza for free, which were absolutely delicious. The customer service was just as great as the food. The staff was friendly and attentive, making the experience even better. If you’re in the area, I highly recommend checking this place out. You won’t regret it!
Sarah J. McCarthy
Mar 27,2025
Very happy! The food was amazing, the place smelled so good, you can tell how much they care about their food will have to sit down and eat next time! Can't wait to come back Pizza is AMAZING
absmithda Go
Mar 18,2025
Hands down the best authentic Italian pizza in the area. I have ordered by the slice and take out and I have never had a bad pizza from this place. The crust is crispy yet light and everything I have had here is always delicious.
Brandy LeBlanc
Mar 16,2025
I’ve always been a big OIP fan - food is consistently high quality, large portions, and the person taking orders & serving food is always happy to serve. Today I ordered my first delivery & the driver was so kind! He delivered quickly & started genuine conversation. He represented OIP well! (Blonde teen - give him props!) Thanks for another great meal!
Strategic BJJ
Mar 9,2025
Great family owned place! High quality food at a reasonable price. Looking forward to visiting again in the future!

Add a Review

Quality
Location
Price
Space
Service

Location

Appreciated by Others

Hud's Amarillo
(987 review)
Hud's Amarillo
  • 7311 W Amarillo Blvd, Amarillo, TX 79106, United States
american restaurant
+1 806-351-1499
Crisp and Green Maple Grove
(547 review)
Crisp and Green Maple Grove
  • 11704 Elm Creek Blvd N, Maple Grove, MN 55369, United States
health food restaurant
+1 763-445-9690
Raj Tandoori Sevenoaks TN15 8BT
(130 review)
Raj Tandoori Sevenoaks TN15 8BT
  • 31 High St, Borough Green, Sevenoaks TN15 8BT, United Kingdom
indian restaurant
+44 1732 882650
Sushi Hana Baltimore
(346 review)
Sushi Hana Baltimore
  • 6080 Falls Rd, Baltimore, MD 21209, United States
Sushi restaurant
+1 410-377-4228
La Casita Mexican Restaurant Kingsland
(156 review)
La Casita Mexican Restaurant Kingsland
  • 5369 Laurel Island Pkwy, Kingsland, GA 31548, United States
mexican restaurant
+1 912-576-9053
CC's Coffee House Metairie
(475 review)
CC's Coffee House Metairie
  • 3647 Veterans Memorial Blvd, Metairie, LA 70002, United States
Coffee shop
+1 504-454-1200
Sugo Johns Creek
(1618 review)
Sugo Johns Creek
  • 10305 Medlock Bridge Rd, Johns Creek, GA 30097, United States
Restaurant
+1 770-817-8000
Burgers & Beer Gibson City
(783 review)
Burgers & Beer Gibson City
  • 109 W 8th St, Gibson City, IL 60936, United States
hamburger restaurant
+1 217-680-5050
The Bro'Kin Yolk AB T6J 5Z8
(840 review)
The Bro'Kin Yolk AB T6J 5Z8
  • 1641 102 St NW, Edmonton, AB T6J 5Z8, Canada
Breakfast restaurant
+1 780-540-9070
Antigua Taqueria la Oriental Pue.
(1502 review)
Antigua Taqueria la Oriental Pue.
  • Av. 31 Pte. 3314, Sta Cruz los Angeles, 72400 Heroica Puebla de Zaragoza, Pue., Mexico
taco restaurant
+52 222 230 2424